Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not quite. There are private hospitals in Canada but very few.

The reason is because physicians are banned from treating patients in the public system and private system. If they choose to treat private patients, they can't work in the public system. With such a small private system, that's not sustainable.

In addition, private hospitals/clinics can't offer certain procedures. MRIs are allowed in some provinces, but the list isn't very long.

Basically Canada is not interested in having any private healthcare system because then it would be "2 tier". They prefer everyone go to the same system.



Any idea why Canada decided to be so extreme - even the UK (which has the overtly socialist NHS) happily has a smaller parallel private healthcare system and a lot of doctors work in both.


"But it was only with the 1984 passage of the Canada Health Act, drafted in the final months of Pierre Trudeau’s premiership, that Canada codified its de facto ban on private healthcare.

The reason was a wave of “extra billing” that had swept Canadian healthcare in the 1970s. Canadian patients were increasingly being hit with user fees and copays that were gradually chipping away at the supposed universality of Canadian healthcare."

Basically, private doctors wanted to be able to also bill the public system and any additional cost the patient is required to pay. That went against the idea that "healthcare should not be purchased".

[1]https://www.capitaldaily.ca/news/private-two-tier-healthcare...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: