Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If Uber can’t turn a profit then how did cab companies (essentially Uber but with a worse product, no software efficiencies, and bad UX) turn a profit for over a century?


They charged more than the service cost to produce.

A shocking idea I know but there we got.


Yes and Uber cannot do that?


Then they would be more expensive than the other taxi firms that aren't pretending to be a tech company.


Because in a lot of locations, they had regulatory capture that ensure their success.


Even if you subscribe to this belief that somehow artificial conditions allow for taxis to exist, you have to start wondering maybe they have a good reason to exist since taxis are pretty much universally available everywhere you go. Even in their previous crappy form, they were ubiquitous like cockroaches. If literally every city in the world adopted this form of regulatory capture, maybe Uber et al can benefit from the same thing, except with a better non-cockroach like UX.


There is also good kind of regulatory capture. Like controlling supply ofc, annoying during night when bars closes, but also on other hand ensuring that someone is there to provide service at night during weekday. Or even capping the prices. And then having enforcement by cancelling licenses if proven wrongdoings where to happen.

System could function... And it did in some countries, apart from supply issues at most popular times. It was bit expensive, but driver's time or vehicles aren't cheap in expensive to live countries...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: