Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I had my catalytic converter stolen. Thanks to location history I could check when I left the car there and when I came back and noticed the problem. Since at first I didn't know problem was result of a theft I didn't take note of the time when I noticed the problem and I also could recall for how long the car stayed there.

Location history enabled me to accurately and confidently report the time window when crime occurred to the police.



Did that help with tracking down the thief too?

I suspect the outcome is still the same of your catalytic converter being gone for good, even if it helped you narrow down details for a police report.

As such, the utility is still zero, since the desired outcome is "get my property back", unless you needed this many details for insurance purposes (they usually only ask for a police report, and police are happy to take any data since they are unlikely to find the perpetrator anyway).


> Did that help with tracking down the thief too?

Of course not.

> I suspect the outcome is still the same of your catalytic converter being gone for good, even if it helped you narrow down details for a police report.

Correct.

> As such, the utility is still zero, since the desired outcome is "get my property back", unless you needed this many details for insurance purposes (they usually only ask for a police report, and police are happy to take any data since they are unlikely to find the perpetrator anyway).

That was not the desired outcome. My desired outcome was to make reporting to the police go as smoothly for me as possible which I'd preferably entirely skip if not for the fact that insurer required me to report it.

Talking to the police (or anyone really) is a stressful event for me so any help with establishing what to say was very much appreciated.

On semi-related note my car is at repair shop for 3 months already and I have no idea how much longer will it be because apparently no supplier of catalytic converters is willing to estimate when they'll have a single item for Toyota Auris.


Sure, but when I had my radio stolen back in the day, police officer politely notified me that they know who generally breaks into cars to steal radios in my area, but unless it was reported in an hour or two, they won't be able to get it before it's resold or pin it on the culprit, so unless I need it for insurance, I shouldn't even bother reporting.

In cases like these, insurance mostly needs a paper trail, and police are very well aware of that, and they won't look for specifics. They'll probably even suggest what to fill in: that's at least my experience.

I feel for your experience though, and I wish you your car back on the road asap.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: