Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Since I've observed a bunch of countries directly, it is more the following:

- Fisheries may not (historically or present day) be a huge part of their economy, and has therefore been neglected for years.

- Not enough infrastructure due to economic neglect.

- Huge revolving door of officials. One month you deal with one person, six months its another one. You don't know if they are real professionals, or someone placed there (party stooge, nepotism, you name it).

- No cooperation between fisheries/marine agencies, and navy/police/coastal guard.

- And, yes, some corruption I'd assume.

I have a concrete example:

We were invited to a developing country to assess their systems, and consult them on how to move forward. They were/are losing millions and millions due to illegal trawling.

Arrive at the HQ, which was a run down office where a handful of people were working. All data was shared via excel spreadsheets, no real systems to work on, lots of paper forms that someone had to digitize. Someone looking at MarineTraffic from time to time.

That's the state of some of these countries.

The illegal fishers are long out of their EEZ before anyone can react.



>All data was shared via excel spreadsheets, no real systems to work on, lots of paper forms

This can be very efficient if you spot check people from time to time, and simply cut the hands off of anyone found to be violating the law.

Tell people to calculate and pay their own taxes too, with the same punishment if they falsify stuff.

That's how Afghanistan dealt with opium farmers before 2001, and it was amazingly effective.


certainly there is a place for medieval law enforcement in this day and age

however, one (of many) problems is that the poachers make more money than the employed bureaucrats .. step 2 - follow the money


Then it seems to be a political/societal issue not unique to fisheries?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: