Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm a logistics consultant that specialises on the software side of things!

What kind of logistics does your company do? (Transport, Warehousing or both?)

Will depend a lot on your functional requirements, but I would say that unless you are doing something particularly unique, there are probably off-the-shelf products that do what you are looking for, and will probably be cheaper and more stable than a 3+ person dev team in house.

I don't know what your requirements are, but if you are in any way a somewhat normal logistics provider, what you are looking to do will quite closely match an existing software package out there on the market (or more likely, multiple packages). Just because you have package which is a poor functional match at the moment doesn't mean there isn't one that better meets your requirements!

In my experience home-grown systems give you exactly what you want in the short-term, and then come with massive limitations as you try to grow/scale them (i.e. if you are on the 3PL side of things, if you get a new client and have a good WMS you can probably on-board them purely with config without having to write code, despite them having some new/unexpected requirements), and the 'new' home grown system today becomes a legacy nightmare in the future.

Plus home-grown logistics software often misses some critical component that makes warehouses function well (e.g. I have come across many that don't have hard allocation, and then find that they have pickface shortage issues that are hard to resolve!). Unless you are closely copying how other software works in this space, you will probably fall into pitfalls that are already solved.

Assuming it is a WMS and you are a 3PL (my best guess from your description!), personally I think the best thing to do is get a good 'off-the-shelf' WMS and then dedicate your engineering efforts into the more customer facing side of things (e.g. customer portals) where you can actually show differentiation with your competitors. No point reinventing something that everyone else already has!

If you are a 3PL on the transport side, there are also great options that cover 'business as usual' and you can again push some development effort towards the customer side.

For logistics businesses, having software which is industry-standard and has a large support base is a bigger sell to a prospective customer than having your own 'great' homebrew software, but that's just my two cents.

Slightly boring answer.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: