Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Looks like they need to blackouts and parades to that simulator...

https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/waymo-paralyzed-parade-b...





The blackouts circumstance was because they escalate blinking/out of service traffic lights to a human confirmed decision, and they experienced a bottleneck spike in those requests for how little they were staffed. The Waymo itself was fine and was prepared to make the correct decision, it just needed a human in the loop.

In the video from the parade... there's just... people in the road. Like, a lot of small children and actual people on this tiny, super narrow bridge. I think that erring on the side of "don't think you can make it but accidentally drag a small child instead" is probably the right call, though admittedly, these cases are a bit wonky.


>The blackouts circumstance was because they escalate blinking/out of service traffic lights to a human confirmed decision

Which isn't really a scalable solution. In my city the majority of streetlights switch to blinking yellow at night, with priority/yield signs instead. I can't imagine a human having to approve 10 of these on any route.


From their blog post they give the sense that they had the human review "just to be safe", but didn't anticipate this scenario. They've probably adjusted that manual review rule and will let the cars do what they would've done anyway without waiting for manual review/approval.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: