All that's needed to cross this "line" is for the creator to say "Yes, this is art" and the question is answered. The creator's intent is enough to make this distinction because art can be so varied and unique that holding preconceptions is self-defeating.
I believe what lies at the core of this point is really the question: "Is this good art?" This is an entirely different discussion that can be answered with some objectivity by judging things such as: "Is this work original or derivative?", "Is it thought-provoking or banal?", "Does it try to expand or otherwise enhance the chosen medium?"
Regarding the bot creator - I'm unable to see a post where he explicitly says that he's an artist or his bit is an art project or that he's creating art. However, if he were to do so then I'd whole-heartily agree and then proceed to explore his creation from an art perspective.
Regarding the bot creator - I'm unable to see a post where he explicitly says that he's an artist or his bit is an art project or that he's creating art. However, if he were to do so then I'd whole-heartily agree and then proceed to explore his creation from an art perspective.
He does actually, in his "Address a criticism" post, he explicitly says he considers the budget for the bot's purchases as money for "art supplies".
He isn't claiming it's art. He's saying that we wouldn't criticize the guy spending $50 a month on art supplies to spread on a canvas with their feet, so what's wrong with his hobby?
It would be difficult for me to defend the statement "random consumerism isn't art" and quite easy to say "random consumerism is shitty narcissistic art"
All that's needed to cross this "line" is for the creator to say "Yes, this is art" and the question is answered. The creator's intent is enough to make this distinction because art can be so varied and unique that holding preconceptions is self-defeating.
I believe what lies at the core of this point is really the question: "Is this good art?" This is an entirely different discussion that can be answered with some objectivity by judging things such as: "Is this work original or derivative?", "Is it thought-provoking or banal?", "Does it try to expand or otherwise enhance the chosen medium?"
Regarding the bot creator - I'm unable to see a post where he explicitly says that he's an artist or his bit is an art project or that he's creating art. However, if he were to do so then I'd whole-heartily agree and then proceed to explore his creation from an art perspective.